Forgive this LONGASS post- apparently to get the nifty "post continuation" feature, I'd have to upgrade my Typepad account. Boooo.
Anyway. I just iTunesed the new "Plagiarism" album by Dillinger Escape Plan, and it got me thinking about bands covering and remaking other songs. I love some, I hate some, but I will always listen to a cover, just to see what how a new take on an old song comes across. Then it occurred to me that cover tunes fall into categories, and this post was born. As usual, it is Rush-heavy.
Feel free to add songs/categories in the comments, or to point out that my lists are ridiculously full of shit.
-----------
Band says: “We love/are influenced by/would sooo fellate this other band - we had to cover them”
Description: Bands covering songs that it makes sense for them to cover.
Examples:
Dream Theater does Rush
Dillinger Escape Plan does “Wish” by NIN
Staind does “Sober,” by Tool
Oasis does "Helter Skelter," by The Beatles
NIN does "Get Down, Make Love," by Queen
Band says: “We want to eff with our fans by playing against type”
Description: The intended result of this type of cover is a “WTF?” reaction by the unsuspecting fanbase. (aka "the ironic cover")
Examples:
Nickel Creek does “Toxic” by Britney Spears and “Spit on a Stranger” by Pavement
Maxwell does “Closer” by NIN
Dillinger Escape Plan does “Like I Love You” by Justin Timberlake
Violet Island does “Afterimage” by Rush
Dolly Parton does “Stairway to Heaven” by Zep
Carbon Leaf does “Crazy Train,” by Ozzy
Band says: “We are contractually obligated to put out a new CD, but have no new material”
Description: Just what it says.
Examples:
The entire trainwreck of A Perfect Circle’s Emotive. Please don’t ever do that to John Lennon again.
Hootie’s Scattered, Smothered and Covered. Please don’t ever do that to Michael Stipe again.
I’m going to include Feedback by Rush in this category, although I think they did it for fun more than for money. (ps- I HATE the song “Summertime Blues,” and not even my most beloved trio of prog-rocks gods will change that.)
Band says: “Let’s do a cover in concert only, so that it goes down in history as ‘that time we covered that one song!’”
Description: Live covers; fans in attendance hold it over non-attending fans' heads for eternity.
Examples:
“Like a Rolling Stone” and “Kashmir” as covered by Bob Weir, Gillian Welch, and The Waybacks. (haha, I saw this performance and y’all didn’t. neener, neener)
“Ashes to Ashes,” as covered by A Perfect Circle (David Bowie tune…APC redeems themselves a tad in the covers department with this one)
Every cover Phish ever did live, including “Gin and Juice” and “Get Jiggy Wit It”
Band says: “Let’s do a cover that is EXACTLY the same as the original!”
Description: Not so much a cover as a blatant rip-off.
Examples:
“Personal Jesus,” as covered by Marilyn Manson (Original by Depeche Mode)
“Lovesong,” as covered by 311 (Original by The Cure)
Fans say: “Wait, this is a cover? (Insert cover band name) didn’t write it?”
Description: This category covers covers the public believes to be the original songs.
Examples:
“Cum on Feel the Noize,” as covered by Quiet Riot (Original by Slade)
“Smooth Criminal,” as covered by Alien Ant Farm (Original by Michael Jackson)
“Hang on to Your Ego,” as covered by Pixies (Original by The Beach Boys)
“Heroes,” as covered by The Wallflowers (Original by David Bowie)
“Dead Souls,” as covered by NIN (Original by Joy Division)
“Last Kiss,” as covered by Pearl Jam (Original by Wilson Frank and the Cavaliers)
Fans say: “Whoa- is that that one song?”
Description: Covers that really differ from the originals, almost to the point of being completely new songs.
Examples:
“Don’t Fear the Reaper,” as covered by Gus (Original by Blue Oyster Cult)
“Tom Sawyer,” as covered by Mindles Self Indulgence (Original by Rush)
“Dancing Queen,” as covered by Glow (Original by Abba)
“The Boneyard - covered to death"
Description: Songs that have been covered incessantly, so that only a few people in the universe remember the original artist. In most cases, Leonard Cohen is the original artist (I read somewhere that there are about 1,000 published Cohen covers):
“Everybody Knows,” as covered by Concrete Blonde (YAY!), The Duhks, and Don Henley (BOO!)
“Hallelujah,” as covered by everyone and their musically-inclined dogs. Jeff Buckley, Rufus Wainright, Bono, k.d. Lang, Bob Dylan, ad nauseum…
“Bizarre Love Triangle” (by New Order) as covered by Frente!, Stabbing Westward, and Commercial Breakup.
“Cinnamon Girl” (by Neil Young) as covered by Smashing Pumpkins, Replicants, Type O Neg, and most recently Matthew Sweet
ps - “Yesterday” and “Come Together” are allegedly the most-covered songs ever.